Blog Archive

Tuesday, September 15, 2026

The long and arduous task of sifting through garbage to find the worst cards

I just got a monster box of stuff from someone wanting to clear out their trash cards and it gives me a chance to show you the process I go thru when I get an unexpected box of unknown cardboard.  And if you want to get rid of yours there will be an address at which you can anonymously send your trash, if you so desire.


Sometimes someone will reach out and warn me that stuff is coming and occasionally it just shows up.  Even if I know a box is coming it's usually someone who says, "Hope you can use these" and occasionally "Just send me something interesting back" while being vague and mysterious as to what they might want in return.  I'm guessing if someone has enough stuff to fill up a box and send it to me, they have more cards than I ever will (or frankly hope to have).  


The count of total cards was north of 100 by a few. It's a pretty good-sized stack, especially considering it only covers about 5 years.  


Step 1. The first think I do is to put each set in numerical order, because they usually come in in a jumble, but in this case each year was already numerically ordered.  nice.


Step 2. Now that they are all in order, I pull out my ever-decreasing list of empty slots in the binder.  I go thru each year and compare the card numbers to the list of binder numbers and make a list of which ones I need.  


Step 3. I go thru and pull out the numbers that end up on the list.  Sometimes I get different cards of the same number so I pull them both (all).  We'll get to deciding which specimen of a given number gets chosen later.

Step 4.  Now I have a stack of things that will fill actual empty binder slots.  Without giving you a full accounting (for a future post) the stack on the right is going into the binder while the southpaw stack are "rejects".  Rejects are hardly that though.


Step 5.  I then sat down with the binder and a couple years of rejects at a time and compare them to what I have in the binder.  You never know. Maybe #613 I just scored in this anonymously sent box of cards is in much worse shape than my Binder #613 and it can be replaced.  I make mental notes on possibilities.  I've been building a 2nd parallel trashed set by doubling up the best dupes.  I call this backsiding a card.  I'm not looking for dupes but in dealing with random lots it's bound to happen.  I don't have to have a sophies choice card show just yet, although I have gotten a few numbers where 3 cards are equally trashy and those are all saved, numerically for easy trading with other trashed card enthusiasts and/or potential future trashed card sets.

(Dupes have grown since taking this picture)


Step 6.  This is basically 5 backwards, but I check all the reject cards against my spreadsheet of the binder.  I'll compare the cards to what is written in the sheet and see if my mental notes on replacement or dupe cards warrant a change.  Actually, I'll go thru the rejects 3 or 4 times, comparing rejects to binder and then to the list and back. And I make a point to do it in different light, day/night, different lamps, etc and at different times just to see if something pops anew somewhere or if a card holds up to what I thought it was.

Step 7.  In doing this much examining of the cards, and I can assure you it is a lot longer by a order of magnitude than your average grading house will spending looking at your Ozzie Canseco card, you start to notice odd things:

Like this is the 3rd time this guy has shown up.  And they all look like someone tried to put a knuckle thru him. 




(From previous episodes)

Speaking of 3rd time, someone has it in for Virgil Fox. 


And I already had worse copies of these 3




Step 8 Typing into the list. The spreadsheet has all the card info, condition notes, historical notes and such things.  I also doublecheck each card and invariably there are a few that are not as trashed as I thought and don't make the cut. I have to simultaneously make sure they have been added to the Trashed F-set collection of my TCDB and update the wants/haves/trade.  Well, I guess I don't have to update the want list because I never know what card I'm gonna actually want.  You can see what cards I have in the trashed set (or any Frankenset) by looking at my collections called Trashed F-Set on TCDB.  


Step 9 Take pics for you. I mean how am I gonna do this blog if I don't take pictures.  I suppose I could hire one of those visuals for the blind services that describes the action on a TV show or movie to tell you all about the cards, just so I don't have to take them out of the binders, but I don't think as many of you would read this. But there are a few that I don't like to take out.  Not because they have the precious pointy corners and sharp edges but, because every time I touch them, they may very well crumple into dust.  


Step 10 putting them into the binder.  Once they are in the binder...well that's it, they are in the binder...and that was the whole point, if I'm understanding this hobby correctly.  

Step 11 sorting rejects.  Many of the rejects don't meet our low, loooooowww standards.  A lot of them are perfectly nice filler cards.  It'll have the usual corner and edge wear, but the creases are usually light and not across the player.  These seem like perfectly serviceable cards for someone building a well-loved set or who needs a place holder card to upgrade.  I get the appeal of a nice sharp card, but I don't really get why a small ding on a corner will ruin it for many folks. It's a matter of degree; how much you are willing to put up with.  And I'm willing to put up with a lot, I guess.  For now, I've got them in the collection but could swap them to trade if someone wanted to build their own set.  If you are looking for ok serviceable cards, I probably have many of them. I need to raise up a war chest so that when an expertly defaced 1933 Goudy comes on the market, complete with mustache glasses and a beard, I can jump the buy it now with less regard to if it is a good deal.  It's never a good deal when I'm buying folks garbage. 

Now, as promised, here is an address you can send your garbage cards to, anonymously if you wish.  I'll still post some of the best cards, I just won't attach your name to the shame.  If you follow the other Frankensets I'm always looking for Ivy Cards, Guys named Dick and Action Parallels AKA Floating Balls in sparkles. 

Randy Lancelot
3347 S. Kinnickinnic Ave #4
Milwaukee, WI  53207
SirNailhead@gmail.com





Sunday, September 13, 2026

They Tried to pick Don Mossi's Nose right off the card!! Who would do such a thing??!?

 I got a pair of cards each from a pair of Ebay sellers.  First up is our old pal RedBirdOctober who had the mockups of Nolan and Thurman RCs.  He did me a major solid on these cards and most of his stuff is in quite nice shape (so go check out his lots of various years at decent prices).  


I just had to have this, Joe Rudi.  It was in another lot, and he was nice enough to pull that one card out of the lot and place it separate so I could grab it.  


To show my gratitude I bought a lot of 60-2 Post cereal cards on which someone had gone to town on this poor chap. 



Stop!  Look at what they have done to Ken Hunt.  I'm mean look at the confidant strokes on the goatee under a perfectly barbered mustache.  The glasses are simple and bold and makes him look like a man of gravitas.  This wasn't some punk 8-year-old kid.  This was his older brother. Greasy long-haired brother who was in high school and carried a switchblade. He knew how to vandalize something quickly and simply while the principal wasn't looking.   A true JD who sniffed glue made this one of the very finest examples of its kind in this whole collection


You really should go check out RedBirdOctober's other stuff on his eBay store.  Their cards are in much better shape, I can assure you.  And he's given me deals that were more than fair.


I scored the Don Mossi for the ages from a fellow state seller.  




Since they deal in high end stuff, I'm not sure if they would want their name to be associated with what someone did to Don.



  They tried to pick his nose off the card!!

Now I would have thought his nose would have been the 3rd or 4th most offensive facial feature on what Bill James wife called the ugliest player of the 50s.

Shortly after that the same anonymous chap got me a dog chewed Casey Stengal to slot in at #29. His own dog, no less.  That's service.





This will mean that I'll have to backside this Tom Brunansky.  I won't pull it altogether because it is the single example that I have of taping things onto a card to make a new card (like RedBirdOctober shared with us).  It would be cool to find more of those types of defacements, should you happen across any you wish to get rid of, dear reader. 


In fact, as I sit here typing this it suddenly strikes me as a brilliant idea gluing Brunansky to the back of Casey so that Brunansky IS the back of Casey.  This would be Frankestiening on so many different levels that is blows right by Ironic and straight into surreal.

And finally, this Bowman gem was used to scrape up the gob after someone hocked a loogie on the dugout bench.  



The look on Cliffs face looks like he got more than a big whiff of the gob of chew, maybe even a taste.  He seem to have one eye partially closed to prevent the juice from burning while his other eye waters and he tries not to yak up his pregame meal.  



Whatever the hell happened this card had quite a story


Friday, September 11, 2026

Stan the Man's Sunset Card Makeover

The Trashed set is a little light on some years, so I was happy to get this stack of well used 1963s.  I love that the seller rounded them up altogether and included several defaced cards with several really beat up cards and let them stand as a group.  Always nice to start off with a simple moustache.


I'm not sure what is going on with Gary Bell.  It almost looks like he has tattooed tears and a gang tag on his chin, which really seems odd for 1963


They ran over Bobby Bragen with some kind of toy truck wheels and give him an almost robot look like Bond Villain Jaws.  





It went all the way to the back of the card too. 


I'm not sure about these two.  They are just on the cusp of being trashed, not just Poor or set filler, and duplicate numbers to boot.  




The idea is not to just have well-loved or low-grade set like some do.  I'm trying to find the worst cards at each number, something that no one else would put in any kind of set no matter how desperate they were for a card.  For now, I'll consider allowing them in the back door, so to speak.  I've been experimenting with reverse numbers for times where there are dupes.  I have 2 cards #116.  So, one of them is slotted in at 611.  If I come up with a bad card #611, I have to replace the reverse number.  But I don't have to actively look for it.  So, Casey Stengel #43 can slot into the blank #34 and the Rookie Parade card #54 will go into slot #45.  I've actually done this with a number of cards across all sets that I had dupes for and Ive even had the necessity to replace a Reversed number card with their actual numbered counterpart.  In some ways this is a set that will never be done as long as I keep an eye out for worse cards.  But if I finished it somehow, I'd probably just start a new trashed set with my dupes and keep it going, maybe adding some new twist.  Like only guys who have nicknames as their first name.  

But I digress.  To sunset this blog post we have Stan the Man's sunset card. I love the addition of eyeliner Curley Qs on his eyes, but I'm puzzled as to what exactly is going on around his mouth.  



Looking closely, it looks like maybe someone was trying to lightly rough out the outlines of a Mario and Luigi mustache.  Or someone was trying to draw a giant earthworm across his upper lip.  


They even drew in a dimple.  I suppose I should photo shop it with the mustache colored in to see how Stan would have looked if someone hadn't smacked the pen out of this kid's hand.  I, for one, feel a great sense of loss that this cardboard Rembrandt was interrupted and deterred from his masterpiece.  







Wednesday, September 9, 2026

Another example of me buying people's literal garbage with real money.

 I got a stack in the mail from a recent Lot from eBay.


Mostly 1959s and a few 60s, to go with a smaller stack of '64s that I too quickly bindered up before getting the pictures



For some reason there are a lot of 1959-60 low grade poor condition cards out there.  The cards from a few years earlier seem to have been a different card stock that tends to be brittle and snap off rather than crease (I'm looking at you '57).



I don't know why the cards from a couple years later seem to crease differently, more in lines rather than the Lysergic Spiderwebs on these.


But the card somehow holds together. 

At first glance this 68 has fewer creases taking hold, almost fighting against them. 


 But the one deep crease in the corner caused a ripple on the back of the card and started to separate fully from the front.  


There are probably scientific papers to be written on the study of the different types of cardstocks and printing technology over the years that resulted in or prevented the damage you now see today.  And I'm not gonna lie, I might very well read them, after I finish Bill James phonebook sized greatest players according to his win shares system.


Sunday, September 6, 2026

Ultra rare 1965 Clemente Eye Patch parallel + has anyone seen Harman Killebrew and Mike Trout in the same room together?

 



First off, who does this to Roberto?  




And what kind of degenerate card collectors start a bidding war that pushes this to almost $40 instead of turning up their nose at a defaced and rough around the edges card instead of turning their nose up at it and allow the purest type of collector, ME, to obtain it for $3.  

I've gotten several offers recently on mid level HOFs cards in bad shape with ridiculous prices.  They all happen to have involved Harmon Killebrew.  First off I noticed this and thought it might be a nice addition for a few bucks.


 $205, that's Two Hundred and five.  That's as much as an actual slab might run and certainly way beyond what this card should be. An Equation: A (HOFer) + B (old Card from 1955) / C (condition that is beyond Poor with a negative grade number possible) does not = $205.  I hesitate to go as far as saying that removing the zero and making it $25 would be fair, but I'm new to this high end game.

That card brought my attention to this card.  


A little better shape, but has been defaced.  I suppose some mad man might pay something for it thinking they could remove or erase the mustache but even $100 seems high for a card that looks like it was used to roll a joint, or really several joints, a lot of them really.  That's probably the genesis for putting a mustache on him and just a simple little line across the lip and it makes the card more desirable. To discerning collectors such as myself.  It sort of makes him look like Mike Trout pasting a mustache on in order to be "anonymous" in some sort of Candid camera show.  

I guess one HK card leads to another and another by the algorithm.  And that is how I found this mold infested 1959.  




It was originally graded a 7 and looks to have been a nice card, but something got into the casing, according to the seller, who is asking the lowest price (of these 3) at $75 for the card that is most heinously damaged because nobody wants to change black mold getting into their collection.  I don't know if the graders guarantee watertightness in their slabs, but if they do, they should be on the hook for this one.  And it makes me wonder just what they were doing to introduce some kind of filth into the process.  If I had more time on my hand, I'd look up the cards with serial numbers that are 5-10 above and below and find out if there was something that was graded at Poor -1 with slime smeared all over.   Say caramel or cracker jack sticky from one of those mid-century sets that got stick residue on their hands to transfer to some other schmuck's card. I don't actually have the time to do that so let me know the results if you do. 



Friday, September 4, 2026

The reason all these sub brand offshoots make me so very happy

 Sometimes it turns out all these different brands that Topps, et al. are pushing turns out to be a blessing.  I wanted to add this Kyle Isbel to the Action Parallel (AKA Floating Balls in Sparkles) Frankenset.  It's got the Bat and the Ball floating, which so nicely ties the two themes up.  


I was all ready to pull the trigger on this, all but sure that there is no card at #220 that I couldn't replace with this one.  

Until I got to slot #220 and found it was the Randy Johnson  All Black.  


His last card, in which he is doing god knows what kind of dance move on a plain black feild with the ball floating away as if he was trapped in the great void of interstellar space.  So that is a no go.  I thought about adding Isbel as a back slide parallel.  Sort of a parallel to the original Parallel card that I often do to avoid a Sophies Choice.  At some point I may have 2 full Frankensets in every binder because of the front and back thing.  But Isbel deserves to be front and center and it would be disrespectful to the very card to give it also ran Status.  

But in looking at the cards he had I came to understand that the same image was issued in the Chrome Set with a DIFFERENT number.  


Now we're cooking with gas.  


I'm not a huge fan of the Chrome series.  I generally avoid the base cards which look flat and lifeless despite their shininess.  The Refractors are better, but they still have the outline on the ball and bat and such that takes away a bit from the image, but hey, this refractor is purple, so it's an even better parallel than a plain refractor.  I do somewhat prefer the flat cardboard parallels.  So, I did more research. Turns out there is yet another number on this image from the 2021 Topps UK edition.  #178 to be exact in black, blue, gold, purple and union jack!! borders and each SNd.  

So far, no luck on replacing it with a UK card, but if you have any of the UK #178 parallels, I'm inclined to give up a lot for it.  Don't care which one.  I probably could go buy the one on ebay for $5, but trading is so much more fun.  So, make me an offer.  


Thursday, September 3, 2026

New Partially authentic Nolan Ryan + Thurman Munson RCs

 A seller on Ebay goes by RedBirdOctober and actually has some good vintage many of you might dig but doesn't meet my, uh,  "standards".  He did have a couple things that I acquired and will talk about later when they arrive, but he also showed me some really great things that he has come across.  


A 1970 Munson duo RC on a '67




Nolan Ryans 1969 RC reimagined on some scrubs 1968



I suppose this kid was mad that their RCs were duo headshot cards that Topps cheaped out on and wanted to remake cool action poses with these, which almost kinda works somehow.  We all know how much their actual RC go, but I have no idea what these new and improved versions would fetch.  I would love to send them in to be graded and slabbed.  If they were sold on eBay at Market value you'd have to send them to eBay for "authentication" which I imagine would cause the grader to stroke out. 


And I have no idea what is going on with scribbling Elliot Maddux name over Richie Allen in 1967

Luckily, he was not looking to sell them at this time.  And I'm not suggesting you all start a petition demanding that he sell them to me.  I personally would never stoop to ask for cards from a personal collection, and I hope that you would not pressure this nice man by starting a Kickstarter campaign to raise the funds to make it impossible not to sell these cards.  That is totally not what I am about.  I don't engage in such pettiness because I'm too busy considering such conundrums as does Munson get filed into slot #189 or #48? Does Nolan Ryan go into slot #231? What did this kid have against Elliot Maddux to rename his Richie Allen card? And why did all the cards suddenly start calling him Dick on his cards mid-career.  


Baseball player eating Ivy in the mail

 My pal Joey sent me a few extra things in a trade for the Ivy Frankenset.  I've got several other colors so I'm now going to try an...